A comprehensive analysis of choosing the best .NET Core SSH server library
In the field of secure remote access, an SSH (Security Shell Protocol) server is essential for enabling secure communication between clients and servers on potentially unsafe networks. For developers using .NET Core, choosing the right SSH server library is critical to ensuring compatibility, performance, and feature richness. This article analyzes the process of identifying and evaluating potential libraries, and ultimately recommends Rebex SSH Pack as the best option, while also considering alternatives such as FxSsh and provide contextual reference.
Needs understanding
The SSH server library allows .NET Core applications to run as an SSH server, accepting connections from the SSH client to execute commands, transfer files over SFTP or SCP, and establishing secure shell sessions. Given the cross-platform nature of .NET Core, the library must support modern versions such as .NET 8 to ensure compatibility with Windows, macOS, and Linux. The library should support core functions such as authentication, file transfer and multi-session, while taking into account document quality, technical support and community feedback.
Selection criteria
The following criteria were considered when determining the "best" library:
- Function: Does it support necessary SSH server functions (such as authentication, file transfer, multi-session)?
- compatibility: Is it compatible with .NET Core (especially the latest versions such as .NET 8)?
- Documentation and support: Is there any complete documentation? Is support (community or professional) available?
- Community feedback and popularity:How wide is the user's scope of use? What is the reliability evaluation?
- License Agreement: Is it open source (free) or commercial (paid)? Is it compliant with budget restrictions?
Preliminary search and candidate identification
Determine the relevant options by searching for ".NET Core SSH Server Library". Preliminary results show that they are more prominent than the Rebex SSH Pack. Further investigation found that it was mainly client library and lacked server functions. So I adjusted the search keyword to "Open Source .NET Core SSH Server Library" and found the lightweight SSH server library FxSsh on GitHub. Later, we used keywords such as "C# SSH server library open source" to ensure that no other candidates were missed.
- ：GitHub repositoryIt shows that it focuses on parallel optimization, but the main functions such as executing SSH commands and SFTP operations are client functions, and the document does not explicitly mention the server functions. Its core types (such as SshClient and SftpClient) are all client-oriented.
- Rebex SSH Pack：Official website introductionIt includes SFTP client, SSH shell and key SFTP/SSH server functions, and supports .NET Core 3.1 and subsequent versions (such as .NET 8). It is a commercial product with comprehensive functions.
- FxSsh：GitHub repositoryIt is an open source lightweight SSH server library for .NET 8.0, supporting SSHv2, multiple authentication methods and file transfer. Derivative projects such as mikaelliljedahl's "freesftpsharp" are also based on this library.
Other business options such as nsoftware's IPWorks SSH were not included in the preliminary comparison due to unclear pricing information.
Detailed analysis
Rebex SSH Pack
- Function: The complete suite includes an SSH server library, supports SFTP, SCP, SSH shell, and provides customized commands, virtual file systems, access control, terminal emulation and tunneling functions.File Server PageDetails on its compatibility.
- compatibility：Download pageConfirm support for .NET 8/7/6/5 and various frameworks, including Mono and Xamarin support.
- Documentation and support：Sample pageProvides 30 C#/examples, commercial products with professional support, and a 30-day trial.User review pageShows good reputation.
- Community feedback: It has been used by tens of thousands of developers since 2003, and its large file transfer performance has received good reviews.
- license: Commercial authorization starts at $899, including one-year free update and a 90-day money-back guarantee.
FxSsh
- Function：GitHub repositorySupports SSHv2, multiple key algorithms, SFTP/SCP, multi-session and tunnel forwarding, meeting the basic SSH server needs.
- compatibility：NuGet packageConfirm that it supports .NET 8.0 and cross-platform operation.
- Documentation and support: README provides basic documents and relies on community support.GitHub issuesIt shows that there are still updates in February 2024.
- Community feedback: 138 star mark, exists as#10 MAC error problemand#22 Security Repair。
- license: MIT open source protocol.
- Function：GitHub repositoryFocus on client functions (such as ShellStream), serverless implementation.
- compatibility: Supports .NET Core but only for client scenarios.
- Community feedback: 3000+ star marks but not applicable to server requirements.
Comparison table
| standard | Rebex SSH Pack | FxSsh | (not applicable) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Function | Comprehensive (SFTP/SCP/terminal simulation/tunnel) | Basics (SSHv2/File Transfer/Tunnel Forwarding) | Client-only features |
| compatibility | Supports multiple platforms such as .NET 8/7/6/5 | .NET 8.0 cross-platform | .NET Core but only client |
| document | Complete documentation + professional support | GitHub README+ Community Support | Client documentation |
| Community feedback | Used since 2003 | 138 Stars + Active Maintenance | 3000+stars but serverless |
| license | Commercial License ($899+) | MIT open source | MIT open source but server-related |
Decision-making process
Rebex SSH Pack wins in enterprise-level applications with functional completeness and professional support. FxSsh is suitable for basic projects with limited budgets as an open source solution. Excluded due to lack of server functionality.
in conclusion
After a thorough evaluation, the Rebex SSH Pack is the first choice for its feature richness and professional support. When budget is limited, FxSsh can meet basic needs. When choosing, comprehensive consideration should be taken based on project needs, budget and support requirements.
Key Quotes
- : Parallel optimization oriented .NET conserved shell library
- Rebex SSH Pack: Comprehensive .NET SSH Client/Server Library
- FxSsh GitHub repository: lightweight SSH server library
- Rebex download page: .NET 8/7/6/5 support
- Rebex sample code: C#/example
- Rebex User Review: SSH Pack Feedback
- FxSsh NuGet package: .NET 8.0 support
- FxSsh Issue #10: MAC Error
- FxSsh Issue #22: Security Vulnerability
- Rebex file server: .NET SFTP/SSH server library
author
Grok 3
translate
DeepSeek R1
Original address
/Aimeast/ae648d1f76bba48858b600517e77bbda